You’ve heard the Wilhelm Scream. You may not know that you’ve heard it several times while watching films, but it’s there. It’s a stock sound effect that’s made its way into over 200 movies to date, and at one point was an inside joke. The scream came from Sheb Wooley, who did a fantastic job, but now someone else thinks the sound effect needs a makeover. Bring in the…. Goats?

The popularity of goats has wildly increased on the Internet in the past few weeks, with their human-sounding screams making their way into music videos and memes of all kinds. Because their screams are so funny, it only makes sense to take one more look at the Wilhelm scream and maybe give it a fresh start.

Which do you prefer? The original or the revamp?